Lesson 28 - To What Extent Can the Law Correct Injustices and Other Problems in American Society?

South Dakota Application

  1. What is the responsibility of the government to address and correct issues of injustice in South Dakota history?

Activities

  1. Have students the following picture from the South Dakota Cultural Heritage Center:

Museum of the South Dakota State Historical Society, Pierre, SD

Based on their interpretation of this picture, have students speculate on the perception of South Dakota statehood to the rest of the country in 1889.

  1. Have students read the following passage from South Dakota: Compass American Guides, pgs. 179-182:

“In the years immediately following the loss of the Black Hills to the U.S. government, some Sioux leaders resisted removal of their people to reservations and agencies which the treaties demanded. Big Foot, knows to some as Spotted Elk, was a hereditary chief of the Minniconjou Sioux of the Cheyenne River Reservation. Regarded as an outstanding chief and a strong believer in the way of life the Indians had known prior to the arrival of the whites, Big Foot eagerly accepted the Ghost Dance religion, taught by Paiute religious leader Wovoka. Big Foot encouraged his people to faithfully perform the ceremony and in so doing rid themselves of white, welcome back their departed warriors, and return to a way of life robbed from them over time.

On December 15, 1890, Sioux spiritual leader Sitting Bull was killed on the Standing Rock Reservation in north-central South Dakota. As tension mounted among Indians throughout South Dakota, Chief Big Foot decided to leave his encampment on the shores of the Cheyenne River and journey with his band to Pine Ridge, where he hoped to join Red Cloud, another Lakota chieftain. En route, Big Foot was joined briefly by more than 40 of Sitting Bull’s warriors who had fled Standing Rock following the shooting of their leader. As he neared Wounded Knee in the dead of winter, the exhaustion, cold, and the 150-mile (240-km) trek had clearly taken a toll on his band of followers – 350 men, women, and children.

On December 28, Maj. Samuel Whitside and about 200 members of the Seventh Calvary (the same regiment wiped out as the Battle of Little Bighorn in 1876) caught up with Big Foot’s band and escorted them into camp along Wounded Knee Creek. Whitside and his officers made plans to disarm the Indians the next morning, take many of the warriors prisoner, and transport them to Omaha, Nebraska, for detainment. Suffering from pneumonia and exhaustion Big Foot willingly acceded to the demands.

The next morning, December 29, 1890, the army of 500 surrounded the Indian camp. At its center, a white flag hoisted a sign of peace, while Big Foot lay in a heated tent. Though the Indians were ordered to give up their weapons, only a few guns were surrendered, so officers began searching tepees. This alarmed the Indians and in the commotion, a shot was fired. Soldiers responded with a barrage of bullets, killings nearly half of the warriors in the first round of the gunfire. Then the Hotchkiss guns opened up, firing on the Indian camp. In only a few minutes, about 200 Indians were dead. Bodies of unarmed women and children were found as far as three miles (5 km) from the initial confrontation, shot down as they ran for their lives across the plains. Twenty-five of the military were killed. Big Foot was shot down in the first volley, his body photographed for posterity. (He was buried in a mass grave with the other victims of the Massacre at Wounded Knee). That night, a sudden blizzard passed through, covering the bodies in a thick blanket of snow.

In the following days, newspapers and government officials referred to the confrontation as a “battle”, but it was none other than wholesale slaughter. Within a year, the army had awarded 23 Medals of Honor to members of the Seventh Calvary for “valor” shown in the carnage. But there was no cover-up of this affair. Even whites were incensed, and from this point on, the systematic extermination of the Indian people ended. With the earlier deaths of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, and the final tragedy at Wounded Knee, settlement of the last true frontier in the West was assured. The blood in the snow at Wounded Knee melted in the spring of 1891, and as it thawed and ran across the prairie in a thousand rivulets, it carried with it a way of life for the American Indian.” 

  1. Have students study the picture (from the South Dakota Cultural Heritage Center) of the Wounded Knee battle site. In a one-page response, have the students respond to the use of the word “battle” vs. “massacre”. Are there other examples from the history of the United States where the use of these terms may be determined by the point of view of the historian? What can be done at a local, state, and/or national level to address and correct such injustices of the past?

  2. Review and discuss the Reconciliation video by Governor Mickelson.

  3. Review and respond to the video clip of the Governor Art Awards of 1984 (Kevin Locke)

 


Dept of Education | State of South Dakota | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

Copyright
© 2004 South Dakota Department of Education
All Rights Reserved